Saturday, November 13, 2010

PPS decides to stick with a good idea.

Harriet Tubman Leadership Academy for Young Women's
original building facade and lunchroom.
Photo by the author.
Sometimes part of the problem with the idea of school restructuring is short-sightedness.

Let me back up. Portland Public Schools have been in the midst of one of the more difficult restructurings it's been through in a while. In a response to shifting demographic trends, the numbers of students in PPS have shrunk over the past couple of decades. Less children are living in the city and more in the suburbs like Beaverton, Sherwood, Tigard/Tualatin, etc. This has resulted in some hard decisions of restructuring of School District #1. The most visible of these was the recent high school redesign process that went through many iterations. Originally two high schools were to be closed. Then one, while Benson became a half-day technical option. But finally it seemed settled with most schools staying as they are with one high school, Marshall, being closed and students reassigned.

Almost shattered in the high school redesign is a nearly invisible diamond in the rough, the smallest of high schools in the city. Harriet Tubman Leadership Academy for Young Women is the only public single-gender school in the state. The Young Women's Academy (YWA) is under the umbrella of Jefferson High School, which is located about two miles north. This school services students grades 6-12, and its future in its current form was held in the balance, slated to be a possible victim of the redesign process. As it is structured right now, there are 63 high school students in the total population amounting to about 1/3 of the student body. YWA has many things going for it that other public schools in the city don't first, unlike Jefferson's failed and shuttered boys academy, the single-gender setting is successful. I have some thoughts about this. For an all-boys school to be successful, it is my belief that it requires the type of structure that is not easy to find in a public school. While boys might see single-gender as a negative, girls see single-gender as a positive; they see it as refuge from the distractions that interactions between the sexes can cause on a daily basis. This school also has a loose uniform/dress code that allows a small amount of flexibility, while maintaining the underlying the, well, uniformity that this code maintains.

Test scores among the higher grades are consistently higher at YWA than they are at Jefferson High School, but due to the way the academy structured being under Jefferson's wing, test scores are reported as a combined data set. Consequently YWA can be making AYP (Adequate Yearly Progress) but because they are still a part of Jefferson, they still suffer from that school's problems. They are also dependent on Jefferson for money, but that's a story left for another post. There was talk at one point of spinning YWA from Jefferson entirely, being allowed to sink or swim independently from the larger high school, but those plans are now tabled. 

As a part of the high school redesign, there was tremendous uncertainty about the future facing the school with one of the most recent plans being to eliminate high school all together and keep the remaining three grades as a middle school in the same form. This was extremely short-sighted. If you are going to think strategically about a problem, you have to be prepared to work on it over the long term. Fortunately, and possibly due to extreme pressure from a dedicated parent base, the YWA is going to continue in its present format, as a 6-12 school. I believe that it would have been wrong for the (so far successful) experiment to be scaled back before it had an opportunity to see the payoff of young inner-city women going to college.

PPS saw the light, and I'm very pleased.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Bad apples? Yes, but some just aren't ripe.

Image by Matt Grigsby, Willamette Week
The writing is on the wall. It's time for bad teachers to be kicked out of their positions. Though Oregon doesn't have tenure per se, in most places it's still unlikely that the "bad" teachers will lose their jobs any time soon. As a newly minted teacher who's looking for a position, it may seem self-serving for me to wish for people to lose their jobs, especially in an economy such as this, but I have some thoughts on the concept of "bad apples."

1. Yes, they do exist. One example of such a poisonous apple was a teacher that I worked with in my student teaching who went out of their way to badmouth other teachers in front of students, yell at her students and demean them, and then have the gall to feel like she was being mistreated. This woman was toxic, and quite obviously needed to not only have her contract not extended, encouraged to quit, etc, but to be out and out FIRED.

2. There is room for improvement. This is the case for any job, and everyone needs to be on board. I recently listened to a segment on NPR's "Talk of the Nation," where Neal Conan was interviewing an author that said that performance reviews were detrimental. His belief was that when managers (principals for this conversation) have a set of benchmarks that they expect an employee to meet, it's a dodge to absolve themselves of responsibility. His belief is that the mark of an effective manager is to help your subordinates be successful, rather than to be a cop who cites the employee when they are committing an infraction. There are teachers who see the principal in their classroom once every two years. That is inexcusable. Also, it's incumbent upon the teacher to be always working to up their game. They need to work with other teachers, to share ideas about how to be more successful. And talking isn't enough. If possible, a principal needs to find a way for teachers to be able to observe other effective (or ineffective) teachers in the school to learn from them. The relationship between the teacher and the principal should not be adversarial, but more as a student/teacher relationship. We're all in this together to make learning more effective for the children.

3. Don't confuse earnestness with effectiveness. I am learning how to play the guitar. It is my sneaking suspicion that I will never be great, despite my earnest interest in the instrument. There are teachers out there that just love being in a classroom, sharing knowledge and seeing a child's eyes light up when they get something. That's great. But it doesn't mean that those are necessarily great teachers.

4. Standardized testing as an assessment isn't unfair, so long as the test makes sense. As much as teachers complain about standardized testing, it's a measure of how well students have done in the classroom. There must be some kind of objective measurement of student progress, it's that simple. A good teacher teaches to the test. "WHAT?" they ask. A good teacher will figure out what the student needs to know, makes the test, and then teaches to that the student will be able to pass the test. If they pass the test well, that means that they know the content that the teachers deemed important. I believe that part of the reason that teachers are so incensed about standardized testing is that they have no control over the content of the test and feel out of the loop. Like their opinion isn't important. Maybe so. Teachers should have more input into what goes into the standardized tests. Then when they have buy-in, they can teach to the test. Finally we can use that as an objective measure to gauging not only the students, but the teachers progress against themselves.

5. The younger generation doesn't "get" why losing your job is a bad thing. I'm not young at the age of 38, but I've worked in the private sector. I've survived layoffs, but also been affected by them. I also know that in the private sector (in the ideal company) results matter. I don't get why this is a tough concept for some people who shall remain nameless to get. It's even more important that results matter when it comes to school, because a degree is one of the better predictors of earning potential in the future. If a teacher is ineffective, people talk about how it is hurting the children, but here's something that I don't think that they think about. If you are ineffective in your job, despite the fact that you may like it, are you really doing what's best for yourself? Are you achieving to your fullest potential. I know that if I wasn't great at my job despite an earnest desire to be great, I should probably move on. Quit trying to be a professional guitarist, and do it as a hobby if that's what makes me happy. But leave room for the talented professionals.

Monday, November 1, 2010

School must be a safe place.


Recently we’ve seen some fairly high profile examples of bullying, in schools. With the tragic case of Asher Brown in Texas to the case of this girl who has cerebral palsy, most of the kids who are bullied have something in common, and that is that they are not “like the other kids.” Take for instance Asher’s case, a 13 year old who just came out as gay. Shortly after he did, he ended up taking his own life, after being bullied mercilessly about his sexuality. He must have been in a very dark place where he didn’t think that the treatment that was being directed at him was likely to stop, and that he had no place to turn. Below is an interview with parent who stepped in under different circumstances and tried to stop it the wrong way. I understand his frustration, but clearly his methodology was misguided.


That’s where we, as educators, need to step in. School and the bus ride to and from school must be a safe place for children and teens. Just like there is a zero tolerance policy for weapons in schools, I believe that there should also be a zero tolerance policy for bullying in schools as well. Teachers need to be absolutely consistent about how they react to bullying and get treatment for the bullied and the bully. Here are a couple of links, one from Fox News, and another from Stop Bullying Now, an anti-bullying website with some specific measures that should be taken to help mitigate the problem.

If a child is freaked out about coming to school, filled with anxiety about what's going to happen to them at the end of the day, during lunch, P.E. or even math class, how on earth are they going to function well in your class? Bullying doesn't just affect their self-esteem, but also their ability to learn, and that is something that can adversely affect their future.

Don't ever think that just because you "got through it" that bullying is in some way an acceptable rite of passage for young people. There are a lot of things that used to be commonplace that are now considered backward and unacceptable. Bullying should be treated the same way. And just because it you can't eliminate it entirely, doesn't mean we should allow an "acceptable level." We must always be vigilant and take the problem seriously.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

You study wrong.



There was a great interview about study habits and the debunking of some of the accepted wisdom. There were several obvious ones like "cramming doesn't work." By "doesn't work" it isn't that you can't cram for a test and pass the next day. What is meant by cramming not work is that there will be an incredible loss of content that evaporates from your memory fairly quickly. What you should do instead is break up learning over the longer term, quizzing yourself. Another piece of advice that I found particularly fascinating is that you should not only break up study by subject, but also break up the study within a subject, moving from area to area. For example: in a foreign language maybe you should practice a little on learning verb conjugation, then vocab, move on to something else. Long periods of studying just one thing will be counterproductive.

Take a listen. It was a very instructive and eye-opening segment.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

School shouldn't be a factory


Sir Ken Robinson talks about the larger structural problems with education. He believes that ADD isn't necessarily a real epidemic, but does see its correlation with the rise of standardized tests and the dismantling of alternative classes like art, drama, music and others that aren't "core" classes. He believes that we are drugging, boring and fragmenting our children in their education when we should be doing the opposite. Brilliant!

Monday, October 11, 2010

Waiting for Clark Kent

Superman's real identity.
Until the 80s, when the famed comic book writer/artist John Byrne helped to completely change the famous Kryptonian's mythology, Superman was a fundamentally different character than he is now. Yes, he still had all of the powers, the enemies, and the famous weaknesses to most kinds of Kryptonite. But until then, the character was the "real" person, and his alter ego just a charade. Happily, Byrne turned that all around, making the mythos far more interesting. He made it so that even though Superman is defined substantially by his alien birth, he's even more defined by his earthly parents, Jonathan and Martha Kent. As we all remember, Clark grew up in Smallville, Kansas. He had to keep his gifts a secret, and he must have had the most understanding parents ever. Anyway, in the new mythology, he probably wouldn't be the man, the "super" man that he is if it weren't for those parents. Clark invented "Superman" as a way to protect his identity, but also be able to fully integrate the values he grew up with and protect "truth, justice and the American way."

So, why am I chattering about Clark Kent. Well (without seeing the movie, but knowing the premise) the new film "Waiting for Superman," posits that we need extraordinary people to go into education and be valued and allowed to use those extraordinary gifts to improve schools, students' lives, and bring America from a second-rate first-world country, a follower, back to being a leader in education. I believe that America needs more Clark Kents, rather than Supermen. We need extraordinary people who are grounded in real values and put on the uniform of Superman when in the classroom. Clark doesn't leave his identity behind when he's out saving the world, he's the same moral creature that he is when he isn't in his costume, though he does act appropriately to the situation. Superman gets all of the accolades, but he isn't the entirety of who Clark is. What Clark does is to de-emphasize his humanity (though he's an alien) and play up the alien parts of his resume to be better in both of his professions.

Teachers are really more like Clark. They become a version, perhaps a stylized and slightly exaggerated "boy scout" in the classroom, but they don't cease being human. They use their gifts in ways to make a difference in the lives of young people. So if you want to be an extraordinary teacher, I say this:

Be like Clark. Act like Superman.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Lewis Black said what I was thinking...

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
Back in Black - Education Crisis
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show Full EpisodesPolitical HumorRally to Restore Sanity
...in a much better way than I ever could. But I have been thinking about this for a while. Because we are still near the beginning of the school year, the president, the media, and others are focusing on education. It seems like education is the newest fad again, and politicians of all stripes are tripping all over themselves and others to pay lip service to education. 

Though I'm happy with the new attention that education is getting, I hope that it doesn't fade back into the background after those who seek to exploit it as an issue find something else to focus on. With that, I can't write anything to improve upon Mr. Black, so I'll let you watch.